As Gillian Forrester has noted,
1 there are similarities between this loose, watery composition, an equally liquid oil study from Turner’s Thames expeditions of 1805,
Willows beside a Stream (Tate
N02706),
2 and the willows and river-bank of
Pan and Syrinx, an unpublished, mythological
Liber Studiorum subject apparently dating from the tail-end of the project in the early 1820s, the drawing for which is in the British Museum, London.
3 There may be a figure (with a dark dot for a head), perhaps in a boat, in the gap between the trees to the left, while towards the right an arch-shaped area appears to have been deliberately left blank, possibly with some architectural feature – perhaps a bridge – in mind. Raphael Rosenberg observes: ‘Wasser is hier sowohl Gegenstand als auch Medium der Darstellung’
4 (water is here both the subject and medium of the representation). In the absence of specific evidence, the span of the
Liber Studiorum’s active publication, 1807–19, is given here as a date range for the present work (as it is for various other unpublished designs).