Joseph Mallord William Turner Venice by Moonlight, with Boats off a Campanile 1840
Joseph Mallord William Turner 1775–1851
Venice by Moonlight, with Boats off a Campanile 1840
D32126
Turner Bequest CCCXV 10
Turner Bequest CCCXV 10
Watercolour on white wove paper, 220 x 319 mm
Blind-stamped with Turner Bequest monogram towards bottom right
Stamped in black ‘CCCXV – 10’ bottom right
Blind-stamped with Turner Bequest monogram towards bottom right
Stamped in black ‘CCCXV – 10’ bottom right
Accepted by the nation as part of the Turner Bequest 1856
Exhibition history
1904
National Gallery, London, various dates to at least 1904 (66, as ‘Venice: Suburb’).
1936
Watercolours from the Turner Bequest [Loan Series G], Empire Loan Collections Society, National Gallery, Cape Town, May 1936–June 1937 (no catalogue, but frame no.17).
1937
Display of Watercolours from the Turner Bequest, Tate Gallery, London, December 1937–September 1939; continuing after the Second World War–December 1952(no catalogue, but frame no.II:22).
1956
Water-Colours by British Landscape Painters (c. 1820 to c. 1870) on Loan from Public and Private Collections, Norwich Castle Museum, November–December 1956 (67, as ‘Venice Suburb: Moonlight’).
1963
J.M.W. Turner, Bridgestone Gallery, Tokyo, September–October 1963, Fine Arts Museum, Osaka, November 1963 (26, as ‘Venice suburb, moonlight’, reproduced).
1964
Turner 1775–1851: Watercolours from the British Museum, London, Presented in Association with the British Council, City Hall Art Gallery, Hong Kong, January 1964 (26, as ‘Venice Suburb: moonlight’, ?1835).
1964
Loan of Turner Watercolours from the British Museum, Graves Art Gallery, Sheffield, December 1964–January 1965, University of Nottingham Art Gallery January–March 1965 (no catalogue).
1966
Turner Watercolours, Arts Centre, Folkestone, January–February 1966 (no catalogue).
1971
10th Anniversary Exhibition 1961–1971: Turner: Major Loan Collection: Theme – Water: Lakes, Streams, Rivers & Seas: Late Watercolours by Courtesy of the Trustees of the British Museum: Also Other Artists Sharing a Common Theme, Arts Centre, Folkestone, December 1971–January 1972 (5, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, reproduced).
1975
Turner in the British Museum: Drawings and Watercolours, Department of Prints and Drawings, British Museum, London, May 1975–February 1976 (231, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, 1840, reproduced in colour).
1992
Turner: The Fifth Decade: Watercolours 1830–1840, Tate Gallery, London, February–May 1992 (70, as ‘Venice: Moonrise, the Giudecca and the Zitelle in the Distance’, c.1840, reproduced in colour).
1993
The Art of Seeing: John Ruskin and the Victorian Eye, Phoenix Art Museum, March–May 1993, Indianapolis Museum of Art, June–August 1993 (no number, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, ?1840, reproduced).
1995
Through Switzerland with Turner: Ruskin’s First Selection from the Turner Bequest, Tate Gallery, London, February–May 1995 (66, as ‘Moonrise (Venice: Moonrise)’, 1840, reproduced in colour).
1996
Turner, National Gallery of Australia, Canberra, March–June 1996, National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne, June–September 1996 (79, as ‘Venice: Moonrise, the Giudecca and Zitelle in the Distance’, c.1840, reproduced in colour).
1998
Moonlight and Firelight: Watercolours from the Turner Bequest, Tate Gallery, London, July–November 1998 (no catalogue).
2003
Turner and Venice, Tate Britain, London, October 2003–January 2004, Kimbell Art Museum, Fort Worth, February–May 2004, Museo Correr, Venice, September 2004–January 2005, Fundació ”la Caixa”, Barcelona, March–June 2005 (96, as ‘Venice by Moonlight’, 1840, reproduced in colour; exhibited in London and Fort Worth only).
2004
TurnerWhistlerMonet, Art Gallery of Ontario, Toronto, June–September 2004, Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, Paris, October 2004–January 2005, Tate Britain, London, February–May 2005 (17, as ‘Venice by Moonlight’, 1840, reproduced in colour; exhibited in Toronto and Paris only).
2013
Turner from the Tate: The Making of a Master, Art Gallery of South Australia, Adelaide, February–May 2013, National Gallery of Australia, Canberra, June–September 2013 (114, as ‘Venice, Moonrise’, 1840, reproduced in colour).
2013
Turner from the Tate: The Making of a Master, Tokyo Metropolitan Art Museum, October–December 2013, Kobe City Museum, January–April 2014 (97, as ‘Venice, Moonrise’, 1840, reproduced in colour).
References
1902
E.T. Cook ed., Ruskin on Pictures: A Collection of Criticisms by John Ruskin not heretofore Re-printed and now Re-edited and Re-arranged: Vol.I: Turner at the National Gallery and in Mr. Ruskin’s Collection, London 1902, p.112 no.66, pl.IV, as ‘Venice’.
1904
E.T. Cook and Alexander Wedderburn eds., Library Edition: The Works of John Ruskin: Volume XIII: Turner: The Harbours of England; Catalogues and Notes, London 1904, pp.214, 373, 611 no.66, as ‘Venice: Suburb’.
1909
A.J. Finberg, A Complete Inventory of the Drawings of the Turner Bequest, London 1909, vol.II, p.1017, CCCXV 10, as ‘Venice suburb; moonlight. 66, N.G.’.
1910
J[ohn] E[rnest] Phythian, Turner, London [1910], p.105.
1930
A.J. Finberg, In Venice with Turner, London 1930, p.171, as ‘Suburb; Moonrise. (Possibly the church and Tower of S. Zaccaria, with S. Giorgio and the Zitelle in the distance on the left.)’, 1840.
1956
Water-Colours by British Landscape Painters (c. 1820 to c. 1870) on Loan from Public and Private Collections, exhibition catalogue, Norwich Castle Museum 1956, p.30 no.67, as ‘Venice Suburb: Moonlight’.
1963
Basil Gray, Edward Croft-Murray and Martin Butlin, J.M.W. Turner, exhibition catalogue, Bridgestone Gallery, Tokyo 1963, p.[25] no. 26, as ‘Venice suburb, moonlight’, reproduced.
1835
Basil Gray, Edward Croft-Murray and Martin Butlin, Turner 1775–1851: An Exhibition of Watercolours from the British Museum London, Presented in Association with the British Council, exhibition catalogue, City Hall Art Gallery, Hong Kong 1964, p.16 no.26, as ‘Venice Suburb: moonlight’, ?1835.
1971
John Eveleigh, 10th Anniversary Exhibition 1961–1971: Turner: Major Loan Collection: Theme – Water: Lakes, Streams, Rivers & Seas: Late Watercolours by Courtesy of the Trustees of the British Museum: Also Other Artists Sharing a Common Theme, exhibition catalogue, Arts Centre, Folkestone 1971, p.[6] no.5, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, reproduced front cover.
1975
Andrew Wilton, Turner in the British Museum: Drawings and Watercolours, exhibition catalogue, Department of Prints and Drawings, British Museum, London 1975, pp.138–9 no.231, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, 1840, reproduced in colour p.140.
1840
Lindsay Stainton, Turner’s Venice, London 1985, p.55 no.48, as ‘Moonrise, the Giudecca and the Zitelle in the Distance’ ?1840, pl.48 (colour).
1985
‘Turner’, The Great Artists: Their Lives, Works and Inspiration, vol.1, part 4, 1985, reproduced in colour p.105, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, 1840.
1987
Andrew Wilton, Turner in his Time, London 1987, p.[174], as ‘Venice: Moonrise, 1840, pl.238 (colour).
1840
Anne Lyles, Turner: The Fifth Decade: Watercolours 1830–1840, exhibition catalogue, Tate Gallery, London 1992, reproduced in colour p.40, p.83 no.70, as ‘Venice: Moonrise, the Giudecca and the Zitelle in the Distance’, c.1840, reproduced.
Susan Phelps Gordon, Anthony Lacy Gully, Robert Hewison and others, John Ruskin and the.
1840
Victorian Eye, exhibition catalogue, Phoenix Art Museum 1993, fig.31, as ‘Venice: Moonrise’, ?1840.
1995
Andrew Wilton, Venise: Aquarelles de Turner, Paris 1995, reproduced in colour p.57, as ‘Crépuscule sur Venise, à l’arrière-plan la Giudecca et le Zitelle’.
1995
Ian Warrell, Through Switzerland with Turner: Ruskin’s First Selection from the Turner Bequest, exhibition catalogue, Tate Gallery, London 1995, pp.98 under no.53, 110 under no.65, 111 no.66, as ‘Moonrise (Venice: Moonrise)’, 1840, reproduced in colour.
1840
Michael Lloyd, Andrew Wilton, Evelyn Joll and others, Turner, exhibition catalogue, National Gallery of Australia, Canberra 1996, reproduced in colour p.148, p.234 no.79, as ‘Venice: Moonrise, the Giudecca and Zitelle in the Distance’, c.1840.
2003
Ian Warrell, David Laven, Jan Morris and Cecilia Powell, Turner and Venice, exhibition catalogue, Tate Britain, London 2003, pp.188, 192, 258, 264 note 29, 272 no.96, as ‘Venice by Moonlight’, 1840, fig.207 (colour).
2004
Sarah Taft in Katharine Lochnan, Luce Abélès, John House and others, TurnerWhistlerMonet, exhibition catalogue, Art Gallery of Ontario, Toronto 2004, p.94 no.17, as ‘Venice by Moonlight’, 1840, reproduced in colour p.95, and fig.13 (colour).
2013
Ian Warrell ed., Turner from the Tate: The Making of a Master, exhibition catalogue, Art Gallery of South Australia, Adelaide 2013, p.213 no.114, as ‘Venice, Moonrise’, 1840, reproduced in colour.
2013
[Ian Warrell ed.], Turner from the Tate: The Making of a Master, exhibition catalogue, Tokyo Metropolitan Art Museum 2013, reproduced in colour pp.172–3 (detail), p.182 no.97, as ‘Venice, Moonrise’, 1840, reproduced in colour.
Writing in 1857, John Ruskin described this watercolour, which he called simply ‘Moonrise’: ‘A highly-finished study, but the locality is here also uncertain [see his comments on Tate D32125; Turner Bequest CCCXV 9]. There are so many campaniles in Venice of the class to which this tower belongs, that it is almost impossible to identify one of them under Turner’s conditions of mystery, especially as he alters the proportions indefinitely, and makes the towers tall or short just as it happens to suit the sky.’1 By the early twentieth century it had come to be catalogued as ‘Venice: Suburb’,2 and the art historian J.E. Phythian then included this work among other Venetian studies he called ‘brilliant in light and colour’ and ‘impressionistic’ in the broadest sense, rhapsodizing at the ‘faintly gleaming light of the rising moon, and the fading sunlight, and the darkness beginning to steal over the waters!’3
In 1930, Finberg suggested that the scene perhaps encompassed ‘the church and Tower of S. Zaccaria, with S. Giorgio and the Zitelle in the distance on the left’,4 meaning that the viewpoint would be off the Riva degli Schiavoni, looking south-westwards across the Canale di San Marco and Bacino to the domed churches on the Isola di San Giorgio Maggiore and the Isola della Giudecca beyond. Andrew Wilton followed Finberg’s suggestion, specifying ‘the Zitelle, with perhaps the Salute on the right’, in ‘[o]ne of the most poetic of the Venetian watercolours’.5 Lindsay Stainton agreed in this assessment, while pointing out that if the topography were as suggested, ‘the view would thus be to the west ... If this is so, Turner must surely be showing the moon setting in the early morning, rather than the moonrise.’6
As Ruskin had, Ian Warrell linked this study with another from this sketchbook (D32125; CCCXV 9), perhaps showing the same elusive buildings.7 He noted the previous topographical suggestions and Stainton’s comment as to the position of the moon; however: ‘Even allowing for the kinds of distortion noted by Ruskin, none of the other architectural features really supports this identification.’8 He subsequently developed a new idea linking the two studies to two more securely identifiable views apparently including the supressed convent of Santi Biagio e Cataldo, overlooking the south side of the Canale della Giudecca from the then somewhat remote western end of the island from which it takes its name (D32128–D32129; CCCXV 12, 13).
He suggested that this and D32125 showed the equivalent point across on the north side, around the church of Santa Marta, also long supressed, then overlooking the open Lagoon but now facing extensive modern docks;9 the plain, barn-like convent church survives as an occasional arts venue, although its campanile was demolished in 1910.10 Warrell has described all four scenes as ‘characterised by sunset or twilight effects that clothe the city in a misty iridescence further frustrating attempts to pinpoint the localities represented’ noting that ‘it is very likely that Turner worked on these views away from the motif, so that while the general points of the remembered scenes were correct, some of the details might have been altered’.11
Warrell has offered the campanile of San Nicolò dei Mendicoli as another possibility in this case; unlike Santa Marta’s, it survives, not far to the east, which ‘would associate the island in the distance with San Giorgio in Alga, with the moon setting behind it. However, the more usual interpretation is that the moon is rising, seemingly lending support to the connection with Santa Marta, which might be viewed from the west in conjunction with the island convent of Santa Chiara’,12 to the north-east, near the north-western entrance to the Grand Canal. This potential prospect is now obscured by the docks, while the former convent serves the city’s main police station, overlooking the railway station.
There are pencil sketches of San Nicolò in the 1840 Venice; Passau to Würzburg sketchbook (Tate D31288–D31289; Turner Bequest CCCX 6a, 7), and Santa Chiara may be seen beyond a campanile in the contemporary Venice and Botzen book (D31851; CCCXIII 31a), a page perhaps also associated with D32125, the other ‘Santa Marta’ colour study. Warrell’s ‘third possibility is that the church is intended as the Gesuiti, with the island of San Michele to the north, though this would remove Turner some distance from the vicinity in which the rest of the studies were made in this roll sketchbook.’13 The church, along the Fondamenta Nuove, is also seen in the Venice and Botzen book (D31891–D31892; CCCXIII 51a, 52).
As well as producing many original watercolour views of Venice, the widely travelled artist Hercules Brabazon Brabazon (1821–1906) was in the habit of making sympathetic if often rather loose transcriptions from earlier artists he admired. He copied several examples from Turner’s 1840 visit in the Bequest, including this one;14 see also under Tate D32154, D32156, D32207, D32209, D32216 (Turner Bequest CCCXVI 17, 19, CCCXVII 22, 24, 31). A more direct copy by Ruskin’s pupil Isabella Lee Jay (working 1868–96) was among others of hers in the Ruskin collection at Bembridge School (now at the Ruskin Library, University of Lancaster).15
See Jeff Cotton, ‘Santa Marta’, The Churches of Venice, accessed 20 July 2018, http://www.churchesofvenice.co.uk/dorsoduro2.htm#santamarta .
Technical notes:
The disk of the moon was lifted out from the surrounding washes, and its reflections were scratched out.
Verso:
Blank; inscribed in pencil ‘7’ circled centre; stamped in black with Turner Bequest monogram over ‘CCCXV – 10’ bottom left; inscribed in pencil ‘N.G. 66’ bottom centre, and ‘CCCXV – 10’ bottom right.
There is a large area of staining or pale grey wash at the bottom left, and splashes or offsets of blue colour down the right-hand side, towards what was originally the sketchbook’s gutter.
Matthew Imms
September 2018
How to cite
Matthew Imms, ‘Venice by Moonlight, with Boats off a Campanile 1840 by Joseph Mallord William Turner’, catalogue entry, September 2018, in David Blayney Brown (ed.), J.M.W. Turner: Sketchbooks, Drawings and Watercolours, Tate Research Publication, December 2019, https://www